The Oakland County Child Killer
What the Hell is the Deal with the Oakland County Child Killer Investigation?
Fifty years after Catherine Davidson disappeared from Warren Dunes State Park in Southwest Michigan, investigators continue to search for answers.
Call the FBI if you have information. The same FBI that won’t touch the OCCK case.
— Read on www.fox2detroit.com/news/search-for-answers-continues-50-years-after-6-year-old-girl-disappeared-from-michigan-state-park
The St. Clair County Sheriff’s Office said it made an arrest last week in a murder case that has been unsolved since 1980. Detectives arrested 70-year-old Douglas Laming of Fort Gratiot in connection with the murder of Karen Umphrey, after working for the last year on a break in the case. Advancements in DNA testing helped lead to a match.
“Working with the Michigan State Police and Othram, a company specializing in forensic genetic geneology [sic], information was uncovered that previously would have been impossible to find. From there, St. Clair County Sheriff’s Office detectives spoke to many people that were connected to the victim and suspect over 40 years ago, gathering information and making vital connections,” officials said in a release.
They WORKED WITH MICHIGAN STATE POLICE AND OTHRAM. See https://othram.com/. If anyone from the Oakland County Prosecutor’s office is reading, I am beyond pissed off. Wednesday will mark one month from my last email to you which remains unanswered. A month ago, that email was in response to your failure to respond to a email from at least two weeks prior.
In April, the OCP contacted my brother and me and we discussed a path forward, which included testing the evidence in the OCCK case by a lab like Othram. Det/Sgt Eric Young of the MSP, who inherited this file, was unwilling to meet with me and my brother to update on on where the case stands and to discuss, among other things, use of a third party lab. His refusal was based in part on the fact that “the sister is difficult.” The sister. I guess that’s me, right Eric?
OCP, if you are reading, I am going to send you an email on Wednesday with MY game plan. If you don’t respond by December 31, I will write about our limited interactions during the past eight months that you have been stringing me along and playing a version of the same game as your predecessors.
THE STATE POLICE KNOW HOW TO PREPARE EVIDENCE TO BE HANDED OFF TO OTHRAM. YOUR FOOT-DRAGGING WILL SPELL ANOTHER FIVE YEARS OF SLOW WALK AND FURTHER EVIDENCE DEGRADATION. MAYBE THAT’S WHAT YOU WANT.
Over it. St. Clair County did it. You can, too.
UPDATE, 10-14-24: Last week a jury found Douglas Laming guilty of first-degree murder in the 1980 death of 21-year-old Karen Umphrey. Laming is scheduled to be sentenced on November 18, 2024. A second suspect, also identified by third-party lab Othram and who testified against Laming, is to be sentenced on November 12.
Child USA is a think tank for child protection. Below is an update on reform of child sex abuse statutes of limitations prepared by this think tank.
The question of when a criminal or civil sex crime or human trafficking case is time-barred, especially in the case of crimes against children, varies greatly state by state. Michigan is discussed in this recent email update, although as of 11/1/23, it received an “F” for its civil statute of limitations revival/window law, which provided only for claims against doctors (the “Nassar” exception) or the Boy Scouts.
The issue of whether and when a victim of child sex abuse or human trafficking can ask for criminal charges to be filed, or file a civil suit for damages against a perpetrator or enablers (employers or the church, etc.) can be complicated. A lawyer specializing in these laws should be consulted. Even with “look back” windows which allow for limited suspension of the statute of limitations, cases from 40-50 years ago are probably time-barred. As described below, Child USA is working on a statute of limitation consulting service, where attorneys would be available to consult on the thorny issue.
Just as a lawyer with expertise should weigh in on the question of whether a claim is time-barred, law enforcement and prosecutor’s offices should have specialized investigators to handle any sex crime. Just because you’ve prosecuted sex crimes doesn’t mean you or the cops who handed the case off to you, know how to best handle these investigations.
The links below are helpful to understanding recent changes in statutes of limitations around the country.
| A 2023-24 SOL Reform Snapshotby Marci A. Hamilton, Founder and CEO, CHILD USA: 2023 has been a good year for child sex abuse (CSA) statutes of limitation (SOL) reform, but not a banner year. Here’s a quick rundown of the SOL picture right now. In 2023, as you can see in our SOL Tracker, 15 states lengthened criminal and civil CSA SOLs and/or revived expired civil claims. CHILD USA and CHILD USAdvocacy’s biggest achievement was Maryland, yes, Maryland, which passed a permanent window that means the victims of child sex abuse should not have to face SOL barriers in their cases anymore. The bill is up for constitutional challenge in 2024, and CHILD USA will be supporting the cases with our highly successful amicus briefing. Maine eliminated the charitable immunity caps, and its permanent window is now being considered by the Supreme Court of Maine. The North Carolina window was upheld in several lower courts on its way up to the North Carolina Supreme Court and the Louisiana window continues to wend its way through the courts. Our amicus briefing was pivotal in all three states, and we will continue to support these efforts moving forward. We also invested time and effort into SOL reform and window legislation that will be on the agenda in 2024. In New York, we will be working on a permanent window as well as a fix to the CVA, which has encountered some challenges in the courts in cases involving abuse in government-based programs. Communities of color were underrepresented in the Child Victims Act cases, and we want to make sure they have the time they need to come forward. There was positive movement for a Michigan window, and we expect to see some changes to the current bill as the window heads to passage and Governor Whitmer’s signature. A window, as well as the elimination of charitable immunity in child sex abuse cases, looks promising for Massachusetts in 2024. There’s some promise in Rhode Island as well. We have also made significant strides in Europe in partnership with the Brave Movement pushing for the elimination of criminal SOLs. Of course, there will be more states and countries considering SOL reform and even more amicus briefs supporting the SOL mission in 2024. We will have two exciting new developments on SOL reform in 2024. First, we are publishing a book on the history of SOLs since 2002, which includes coverage of the 50 states, territories, and the federal government and specific issues including tolling and discovery rule analyses. It is a collection of years of research and thousands of hours of analysis and writing that will be useful for every attorney and law firm working on child sex abuse issues. Second, we will be instituting an SOL consulting service. If you have questions that are not answered by the copious information on our law page, you will be able to speak with one of our attorneys to work out thorny questions in this space. Stay tuned for announcements on our upcoming SOL book and consulting service! |
| Visit our Website |