Other $10,000 questions.

Last weekend I received an email from someone who grew up in Oakland County and was very young when the OCCK crimes occurred. After recently reading about these crimes, the reader immediately honed in on the following.

The most striking thing to me is; how could I as a 50 year old that grew up in [Oakland County] and lived most of my life in southeast Michigan [. . .], have never heard the OCCK or north fox island stories?

In a broader sense, how could the North Fox Island story not be known widely as a national tragedy?

Against the backdrop of the Epstein/Maxwell human trafficking and pedophile ring, these are especially important questions. Here is my take on how and why these crimes were kept under the radar or on the back burner over the past many decades, or at least how they were easy enough to miss if you were very young when, or born after, they happened. It’s long-winded. Sorry.

Before I had my eyes opened, I believed that “back in the day,” maybe sex crimes against kids were just too much for law enforcement to handle mentally and emotionally. That’s why they didn’t go there, if they believed the crimes took place at all. Ridiculous, I know, but if you would never even think to rape a child, it’s hard to wrap your head around such a crime. It’s hard to wrap your head around someone with a wife, family and a good job who would pay for a child or a teen to do god-knows-what to. It’s hard to wrap your head around a family member raping a young relative. It’s hard to wrap your head around someone watching, let alone creating, CSAM that sometimes involves infants. It is so depraved it can seem almost impossible. But it is sadly anything but impossible and don’t kid yourself: These sex crimes can easily escalate to murder.

If it’s the mid-1970s in Birmingham, Michigan (let alone the 1960s and 1970s on N. Fox Island), “kid-diddling” wasn’t a big deal. Property crimes? Traffic control? Or, god forbid–marijuana; now you’re talking. So Chris Busch exposed himself to your daughter. Nobody got hurt, right? He’s harmless! The thought of organized pedophilia in Bloomfield Village? No one would believe it except the survivors. Fly to N. Fox Island to rape boys? Why, those men went there to hunt for deer and discuss charitable contributions with Frank! The survivor was rarely believed over the word of an even half-way presentable pedophile.

But it was much more than ignoring or downplaying sex crimes in Suburbia. If you want to be charitable in your evaluation, it’s L. Brooks Patterson refusing to let the cat out of the bag that raping kids was just as big a business north of Eight Mile Road as it was in the land of Richard Lawson, Ted Lamborgine and Bobby Moore in the Cass Corridor. As a reader commented years ago–it wasn’t just the Cass Corridor. It was also Cass Lake. This was very, very bad for Patterson’s brand.

Even in Detroit, it appears that pedophile Richard Lawson was a confidential informant for Ike McKinnon at Detroit PD not to arrest child rapists, but to find drug dealers. I know it seems hard to fathom today, but it was far worse back then to sell marijuana than to sell a child.

Back in Oakland County, during the reign of the OCCK(s), Patterson was laser-focused on using the prosecutor’s office as a stepping stone to much higher office. This kid-killing shit was bad enough for business; there was never going to be a close examination of the pedophiles in suits and ties in Oakland County, or claims of a “child porn” and sex ring operating out of GM corporate. After all, there were fundraisers to attend and campaign stops to make around Michigan. See Guarded by Jackals.

Based on what I’ve seen and read, I don’t choose the charitable evaluation. I believe Brooks Patterson closely controlled the media coverage of the OCCK crimes even after he and his cunning #2 foisted the case off on the Michigan State Police, and that it was he who ultimately controlled the narrative about those crimes basically until the day he died. It is he who made sure these crimes faded into oblivion, unless it was something he tightly managed as needed. The failures on his watch were not to be discussed, let alone dug into.

Nothing to see here; it was a lone, maniacal killer who really just wanted to hang out with the kids before returning them to God or Satan, where they would be better off. I have written this before–a friend whose dad was a counselor in the Birmingham Public Schools told her that after Tim’s murder they were all instructed NOT to talk about these murders. Imagine that. The impact on the community was basically ignored after a brief period of high-pitched panic. The victims? Their names were rarely uttered or their memories honored. This was not in any way Austin, Texas post-the 1991 Yogurt Shop Murders.

After a relatively short time, no one talked about the crimes. No one demanded answers. The sheeple, my family included, fell into line. Many murders are never solved. Tough break. Move on. It’s still a great place to raise the kids!

I further believe Patterson knew to some degree what was going on with these pedophiles in his county and that he was taking campaign donations from them whether he knew it or not. I believe he cut Chris Busch loose in January 1977 as a favor to or on behalf of H. Lee Busch, who may well have been an even bigger pedophile than his youngest son. What Patterson, his chief deputy Richard Thompson and investigator Gary Hawkins knew at that point will remain forever unknown. But at a minimum, after my brother was abducted on March 16, 1977, I am quite sure these brilliant wheeler-dealers suspected or damn well knew that they had screwed the pooch.

They knew on March 16, 1977 that Chris Busch drove a blue Chevy Vega with a white hockey stripe, a car closely resembling a blue Gremlin with a white hockey stripe. They knew the older woman who described the car to police said it “may” be a Gremlin, not that it WAS a Gremlin. Old women, and I am now one of them, don’t tend to keep brain space for makes and models of cars. Patterson and Thompson probably correctly surmised that the disgusting and very identifiable bearded fat ass, Chris Busch, was sitting in the Hunter Maple parking lot in his Vega, observing the abduction of Tim and facilitating what happened next. As pointed out in Guarded by Jackals, no one swung by Morningview Terrace, 2.5 miles from the abduction site, to see what Chris Busch was up to the week my brother was being held captive.

And they knew for sure that they would be fucked if it ever got out that Chris Busch was suicided in his bedroom at H. Lee’s house in November 1978 and the room converted to a scene that screamed “I am the OCCK!” So they managed to keep that shit under the radar until some seams cracked in Hell and Larry Wasser spilled the beans in 2006 about his attorney pals’ pedophile client, who turned out to be Chris Busch.

There was occasional mention in the news of the OCCK crimes between December 1978 and 2005, but not much more beyond the pathetic “anniversary” coverage by the area networks. That’s a long, long time for a story to calcify into a couple of rote and basically meaningless sound bites.

I want to highlight that at no time after 1978 did anyone in law enforcement or the prosecutor’s office say: We will never give up. We will never forget these four preteens whose lives were snuffed out. If you find such a quote, either on the news or in print, please send it to me. They mostly just tossed quotes about how hard they had worked or were working and how they just didn’t get the tip they needed. Unlike almost every other cold case you hear about that is solved, they never said: We will continue this work on behalf of these four little kids who cannot speak for themselves. They were more concerned about avoiding “useless” tips. They didn’t say “we will never give up,” because they knew they did just that in December 1978.

All the good old boys knew or suspected this investigation got decapitated and then shut down because the decision was made that these crimes would never be solved. Best not to ask or comment. By the time a task force was “rejuvenated” decades later in 2005, one detective would begin the painstaking efforts of doing the work that should have been done right after Mark Stebbins was abducted and murdered in February 1976. That’s a lot of water under the bridge between 1976 and 2005. I believe this detective was thwarted by two Michigan State Police detectives for reasons that range from professional jealousy, to fucked up agency culture, to protecting those who participated in the failure to solve these crimes. In so doing, these two also betrayed the child victims.

Why didn’t you hear much about the case between 2005 and 2019 when the investigation went from life support to once again freezing cold? Because the one reporter who wrote a big story on the case in 2009 for The Detroit News then embedded with the Wayne County Prosecutor’s Office and one of the detectives in order to write a book. The 2020 book was an excellent recap of parts of the investigation post-2005 that the public benefitted from knowing. However, there would be next to no print reporting by that paper after 2009. The reporter turned author and later retired from the paper. No one pressed law enforcement for answers in real time that would be published in the paper to keep the case in the public eye.

The one reporter who wrote a two-day series for the Detroit Free Press in 2012 left the paper soon afterward, allegedly with (but apparently not because of) complaints about the editing on his work on the OCCK investigation. No one really picked up the case in a big way at either major newspaper in the Detroit area ever again. No one even has asked about DNA testing in the wake of so many DNA solves in very old cases around the country since 2019. Crickets. Seems to me like a worthy line of questioning the public might be interested in.

I stress that L. Brooks Patterson was very much alive and still the Oakland County Executive when these two big stories were printed by the two biggest Detroit newspapers. There is no way this man was not all over all of that reporting and shitting his pants. Also, know that the MSP contacted the News after the 2009 reporting, complaining that “their” crime reporter hadn’t written the article. I believe both agencies were pressuring the newspapers. Whatever the reasons, there was never any real follow up. This allowed the public to assume the cops had it under control and that the Busch lead had been properly and thoroughly investigated.

Surely someone would investigate any connection between Busch and Shelden or N. Fox Island, right? Surely someone in law enforcement would listen to survivors of Chris Busch or H. Lee Busch? Wrong and wrong again.

It also did not help that the Oakland County Prosecutor during this time period (2008-2020) was Jessica Cooper. She, along with her #2 Paul Walton, further manipulated the press. I believe she was deeply spooked (as well she should have been) by the civil lawsuit filed against Oakland County in 2012 by Kristine’s mother, Debbie Jarvis. I also believe she was all-in for Larry Wasser, the private polygrapher of Chris Busch who worked for Cooper’s old pal attorney Jane Burgess. She and Walton appeared to have no problem lying to the press. No need for the smoother bullshitting skills of LBP. The 2012 press coverage of her b.s. press conference was worthless because she was worthless and using sleight of hand. Just my opinions; feel free to vouch for her in the comments below if you believe otherwise. I believe her reign did much damage to the OCCK investigation and transparency, on top of what had been done by her long-ago predecessors.

The network coverage of the OCCK case was primarily what it almost always is–empty calories, until the eve of the release of the documentary Children of the Snow in early 2019. Then Channel 4 pulled a bunch of its old footage (which they had previously denied to another documentarian) and did a good job interviewing two men who had been taken to N. Fox Island. They created some two-part series they aired the night before COS aired. There hasn’t really been jack shit by these networks since. (Books, podcasts and YouTube videos have filled some big gaps.)

Furthermore, the cops in this case have ALWAYS hid behind the “open case” bullshit or the “nothing’s up” line to evade any substantive comment about what the hell has or has not gone on in these cases. Not easy to put together a story when the cops shut down the conversation in what is now an almost 50-year-old case.

In the Yogurt Shop Murders in Austin, the cold case detective who shepherded the case to a recent solve not only told the families to their faces what was up with the DNA testing as it was in progress, he did so in front of a documentary crew. He didn’t play hide the ball; most communities see through that shit and don’t appreciate it. He told the camera: I want the public to know these murders are going to be solved some day. And then soon afterward, due in large part to him pressing the DNA testing at every level, they were.

In the OCCK case you have to happen upon a documentary, podcast, YouTube video, or read a book to get the bigger picture of these tragic and heinous murders and why they have never been solved. In the case of Frank Shelden and N. Fox Island there is much, much less to fill in the blanks or remind the public of the dark crimes Shelden never paid for and his many, many victims. He was like some other criminals I can think of–an “enigma.”

So it’s no surprise most people living in Michigan today know nothing about the OCCK crimes or N. Fox Island. The news coverage was never adequate and I believe this was due mostly to L. Brooks Patterson’s long shadow, first as prosecutor and then as county exec–a position he held until he died in the saddle in August 2019.

Nobody asked the hard questions or had the difficult conversation as all of the fuckery in this case started to be exposed in 2007. No one pressed the obvious players in the cover up of this case or those who knew or should have known. And, no surprise, some of them have since died before someone could report their “no comment” or “I don’t recall” in the press. These things were not in the news in real time, when the public could have pushed for greater transparency when it maybe would have made a difference. The public thinks it was all ok because the press never circled back!

Another 18 years have passed and believe me when I tell you there are still people living who wish everyone would just shut the fuck up about the OCCK crimes, the four child victims be damned. It worked in the case of Frank Shelden and N. Fox–why not in the OCCK case?

In Southeastern Michigan people still eat up details about the 1975 disappearance of Jimmy Hoffa. They discuss the possibility that after he was quickly dispatched (unlike the four kids in the OCCK case) his body was put through a meat grinder. (Again: Who the fuck does that?)

That’s what metro-Detroiters want to hear about or at least what reporters want to discuss. Not four little kids who were held captive for a total of over 30 days, kept alive for reasons you don’t want to even think about, suffocated and dumped on roadsides like garbage. They don’t want to think about the real reasons those murders have never been solved. They don’t want to learn about things they don’t really want to consider.

And just like the federal government in the Epstein/Maxwell case, the State of Michigan was all too happy to keep that pedophile shit about wealthy philanthropist and bon vivant Frank Shelden, and all of the white collar pedos he brought to N. Fox, under the radar. Pulling the thread on that guy and his “clients” would have been an implosion for tourist-loving Northern Michigan as well as the white collar set in he rolled with in and around the Detroit, Port Huron and Ann Arbor areas and even Aspen, Colorado.

GM was probably the biggest paying advertiser in metro Detroit during that era. Who was going to ask about Chris Busch and his daddy, even if the word did get to the media about his “suicide”? If they did ask, who was going to let the story run at the big Detroit papers?

Those are just some of the reasons these sick Michigan crimes come as a surprise to the majority of people who live there and have never heard of them.

It is more by design than neglect.

–You know where to find me: OCCKTruth@protonmail.com. I read every comment but don’t post them all. I read every email, even the double-secret/decoder-ring/beware of the occult/how dare you/do better/do more emails. I am almost, but not quite, hopelessly behind in responding to emails from this summer and fall. I respond to most, but not all, and I’m sorry–not necessarily promptly. I really do appreciate the vast majority of the communications. Thanks for your understanding.


Discover more from The Oakland County Child Killer

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

10 thoughts on “Other $10,000 questions.”

  1. Cathy, You know about where I live. For the past several months, Ch. 4 News in Detroit is constantly running the same TV commercial about Jimmy Hoffa. It is the same thing for the past 50 years. Both the Feds and the Mafia know what happened. They know where the body went and so forth. You will never see anything like this about OCCK.

    1. The OCCK case is radioactive and will remain so until long after the PsOS who derailed this investigation, not to mention every participant in the crimes themselves and those who knew and stayed silent, are long dead. But just like those fuckers didn’t see DNA testing evolving at lightening speed as it has, they didn’t see podcasts, YouTube videos, books and documentaries flooding the zone either. Those creators don’t care about radioactivity. They specialize in it.

  2. Cathy, I’m so sorry for all your family and the three other families have had to endure. I am one year older than you and was living in B’ham during and after these years. It’s appalling that our police and politicians didn’t do their jobs. We need to get the DNA testing done on whatever they have boxed away??

    1. Thanks very much, Kathlene. And yes, they need to test and/or retest all of the evidence. I am going to post about how the state seeks to benefit from the failure to properly handle and store the evidence by arguing it will yield too much wild-card DNA from people who handled the evidence, and resisting the retesting using current methods of DNA extraction on, for example, the kids’ clothing.

  3. I am almost a decade older than the reader mentioned in this post, and you couldn’t miss seeing things about the OCCK is 76/77. However, it was shocking how it all just went away around 1978. Of course, the citizens of Oakland County had no idea why, for some reason it was just thought “well he must have died” (back then it was very much reported it was a single killer). Its unbelievable how the case went from being the most investigated case ever (or something like that) to virtually non-existent. So being born in 1975, this case was long disposed of by the time this person got to the age of having memories.

    Regarding N. Fox Island, I never heard of it was brought up here, and I have lived in SE Michigan my whole life. Most people that don’t follow the OCCK probably still have no idea. Most probably still think Brooks was a great guy.

    In the words of Fox Mulder from the XFiles, the truth is out there. Unfortunately it is buried so deep it may never see the light of day.

  4. Back to Busch being the killer? Nope. The killers of your brother were John Hastings and Bloomfield cop Richard McNamee. I’m not sure how many of the four murders McNamee was involved in but a witness at the 7-11 in Berkley saw Kristin by a police car outside the store. The Hastings all bowled across the street at Hartfield Lanes. In fact, Hastings sister, Mary Mergos is good friends with Linda(?) Hartfield.

    1. The real point is, Greg English–and it’s hard to rehash it all in every single post, so I appreciate the chance to clarify what my position is–the problem, and the reddest of red flags, is that NONE of these men were adequately investigated or ruled out as being involved or being linked. You have ruled out Busch, but I would say not so fast. I’m not trying to put all the chess pieces on the board here, but it goes without saying if you have read my blog all along, that there are a number of serious suspects who were worthy of very intense additional scrutiny. I’m not going to footnote Hastings and every other serious suspect in every post.

      Law enforcement wanted to talk all day long about Ted Lamborgine or Arch Sloan but the following men from Oakland County were dismissed basically with a shrug and perhaps some reliance on the hair evidence, such as it was, excluding them. And the real story is why, in the face of evidence that has turned up since 2007, were Busch, his father, John Hastings and Richard McNamee not looked at under a microscope by law enforcement? Hastings is still alive and so are his siblings, last time I checked.

      So “we” are on the same page, here is what the record I have seen shows.

      Hastings–it is hard to argue he is not involved, as I have posted many, many times. The FOIA documents we got from Birmingham PD in 2020–documents a commander there found after an extensive search for any documents that might not have been turned over to the MSP–admit of no other conclusion in my mind. While a tip was turned in on Hastings soon after my brother’s abduction, he was never really on the radar until Helen Dagner went to B’ham PD in 1992. FOIA documents from the 1992 investigation were in the MSP FOIA response, and rather than supporting the conclusion (via polygraph on my brother’s case only) that he was “cleared,” only raise alarm bells. The transcript of an interview of Hastings by Garry Gray and Cory Williams in Georgia in 2009 is hardly reassuring. And the man shows up for the interview with the Big Book of Serial Killers, to prove he’s just a s.k. aficionado. Worst of all, in 2009 Garry Gray deep-sixes the polygraph results from the Georgia Bureau of Investigation indicating deception in the polygraphs concerning the three other murders (they didn’t retest on Tim’s case). AGAIN, the polygrapher tells Gray he believes Hastings was involved–he’s not sure exactly how–and that he was lying when he said he didn’t know Chris Busch. NO ONE CIRCLES BACK TO HASTINGS. In my letter to the Oakland County Prosector in January of 2021 I outlined all of this and re-interviewing and investigating Hastings and his family members was at the top of my list.

      A little more about Hastings and a connection between him and his neighbor Christopher Busch. As I have also posted before, a survivor of child trafficking from that era and in and around Oakland County credibly links John Hastings to Greg Greene and Christopher Busch. Places him in “the waiting room” at places where kids were taken to be filmed for CSAM. Sometimes both John and his brother whom I assumed, given the age description, to be Tom. Basically said John was the little bitch in the group–just a weirdo who was tolerated (perhaps “just” a kid snatcher or “babysitter”), was scared to death of Greg Greene, sat around with a sketch pad. Law enforcement thought this survivor was just putting Hastings on the chessboard, so to speak, in order to add him to the “story.” That she had read about Hastings online and somehow made this part up.

      That is not to say JH couldn’t have gone rogue–or with McNamee, as you describe–and kidnapped my brother and kept him at his house on Tuckahoe. But as far as I’m concerned, he has also been credibly linked to Busch and Greene and that entire child rape/CSAM operation. As the Georgia polygrapher concluded–he is involved or has knowledge. Hastings was never properly cleared and never properly investigated. His siblings and parents appear to have lied on his behalf during the 1992 investigation. Nothing in the above post should be read to support your conclusion that I think JH is not involved at some level.

      Richard McNamee–Bloomfield Township/Village PD Officer McNamee’s name came to light after Marney Keenan’s book was published in 2020 and a reader was shocked to read he was the responding officer to Busch’s “suicide.” She then read the FOIA documents on this blog. Marney Keenan obtained McNamee’s police file via FOIA and I posted the documents on this blog. He was a pedophile, lived on a cop’s salary just adjacent to the Busch and Hastings streets in the Village, responded to the Busch death scene, “liked” girls and boys, and he was given the heave-ho by Bloomfield PD without censure or a bad recommendation.

      The bigger issue with McNamee is that I immediately provided his name and the information to MSP Det. Sean Street who had previously told me I could contact him with information. He blew me off. Played dumb, didn’t touch it. This is the kind of gaslighting that I have been writing about for over a decade. McNamee has been dead for many years but I think he has a kid or two–a son for sure. So there is a possibility for obtaining a DNA sample. NO ONE IN LE CIRCLED BACK TO MCNAMEE.

      Busch–I think even you will agree with me that in light of the “suicide” scene in November 1978, police should have investigated whether or not any of the four families knew of or ever interacted with anyone in the Busch family. Same goes with Hastings in 1992. There were ways to handle this line of inquiry without dropping the actual names. The evidence of Busch’s involvement is just too compelling in this case to dismiss him out of hand with a “nope.” Same with Hastings. Furthermore, what went on with the polygraph evidence in January 1977 (both Busch and Greene) is dirty and demands additional investigation concerning this obvious cover up on Busch’s behalf. Part of the story, like it or not, is that a pedophile/CSAM ring was flourishing in Oakland County and should have been thoroughly investigated as part of the OCCK investigation.

      H. Lee Busch–he was never investigated, never even really interviewed about knowledge of his son’s possible involvement in the OCCK crimes. A credible survivor has described being sexually assaulted by him when he was a young teen. Two other survivors have credibly described H. Lee’s house as a place they were taken to for “pedophile parties.” More has unfolded on this man and no one will touch it.

      The point being, is that if this were a real cold case investigation, all of these men would have been much more carefully investigated and they weren’t. Busch gets suicided and that’s the end of the story? Hastings is his fucking neighbor, flunks polygraphs in 2009 and that’s the end of the story? A pedophile cop responds to the Busch house when Charles Busch calls in a wellness check, and that’s the end of the story?

      And to the point of my post–no one in the press writes in real time about any of these failures, all essentially brought to light by civilians? Why would someone know about any of it unless they were following true crime-type media or had been touched by these cases back in the day?

      After almost 50 years, law enforcement cannot say who was involved–lone killer, priest, wealthy patron who paid for kids to murder, group killing; or even whether all four cases are even connected. But if you are certain enough, good for you.

      Which brings me back to the DNA evidence. Since no one will follow up on any of these Oakland County suspects, all of the evidence in the OCCK case must be tested/retested using the most advanced DNA technology currently available. Maybe you will be proven correct in your assumption that it was Hastings and McNamee who killed my brother. More likely, any foreign DNA linked to someone other than a cop or a lab worker, will be linked to someone who will conclusively demonstrate at most that there were multiple men involved in these crimes. The failure to get any traction in this investigation will be that much more shameful.

  5. Also, if the police were involved in “suiciding” Chris Busch, Richard Hojnacki and/or murdering John McKinney, there is no way those can of worms or any associated cans (like John Hastings) were getting opened. Ain’t nobody going to prison for killing one of those men, if these were in fact “assisted suicides.” (Enter their names in the search function if you are unfamiliar with them.)

    1. As a Michigan resident I have read your site off and on for years, Cathy. Thank you for everything you have brought to light.

      This has always struck me as the most plausible theory for the police malfeasance. If the cops just let sickos off with a slap on the wrist and they went on to kill, I feel this would eventually come to light and the police would come clean. Sadly, this happens all the time in many jurisdictions with crimes of all sort.

      But if the cops went on a “suiciding” spree to cover their tracks, that could explain such a successful and longstanding coverup. Of course, I have no clue.

Leave a Reply to cathybroadCancel reply

Discover more from The Oakland County Child Killer

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Discover more from The Oakland County Child Killer

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading